"Tribunal"
(Sud)

Sezona: 2
Epizoda: 25
Datum premijere: 05.06.1994.
Prikazano na HRT-u: 16.12.2008.



Scenarist: Bill Dial

Redatelj: Avery Brooks

Gostujući Glumci:
* Rosalind Chao - Keiko O'Brien
* Caroline Lagerfelt - Makbar
* John Beck - Raymond Boone
* Richard Poe - Gul Evek
* Julian Christopher - Kardasijanac
* Fritz Weaver - Kovat

Stardate: 47944.2 (2370)

Kratak sadržaj: (preuzeto sa ST centra)
Dok ide na odmor s Keiko, O'Brien nailazi na Boonea, bivšeg suradnika s Rutledgea. Oni izmijene pozdrave i O'Brien se žuri, željan što prije stići na zasluženi odmor. U svojoj brzopletosti on ne opazi kako je Boone snimio njegov glas. Kasnije on i Keiko idu prema svojoj Risi jednim od šatlova, ali ih presreće kardasijanski brod. Na Keikin užas, Gul Evek teleportira se u šatl i uhiti O'Briena, te ga odvodi na Kardasiju Prime ne otkrivši mu za što je optužen.

Detaljnije informacije: Memory Alpha

Kompletan scenarij: ST Minutae

Pozadinske informacije:
* According to the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion, "Tribunal" is a so-called "O'Brien Must Suffer" episode.
* The original title of this episode was "Dark Tribunal".
* Although generally well received by fans, "Tribunal" has been criticized for having a deus ex machina-style ending.
* The plot of the episode was based on a statement made by Gul Dukat: "On Cardassia, the verdict is always known before the trial begins, and it's always the same." (DS9: "The Maquis, Part II") As Ira Steven Behr states, "That one line gave us the concept for the whole episode." (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion)
* The discussion to which Evek alludes occurred when O'Brien contacted Evek for assistance in exterminating a colony of Cardassian voles that had made its home aboard DS9. At the time, he was credited simply as "Cardassian Officer." (DS9: "Playing God")
* Andrew Robinson (Elim Garak) has likened the Cardassian brain to the reptilian portion of the Human brain, which, in Robinson's words, "knows what boundaries are ... [and] how to take care of itself so that the species survives." [1] Consequentially, Cardassian philosophy places order above both freedom and equality, resulting in an Orwellian society where the good of the state is placed above that of the individual. Kovat epitomizes this philosophy in his defense of the legal system: "Whatever you've done, whatever the charges against you, none of that really matters in the long run... This trial is to demonstrate the futility of behavior contrary to good order."
* Production designer Herman Zimmerman has said he took inspiration in the set design for this episode from George Orwell's 1948 book Nineteen Eighty-Four, and of the final look of Cardassia, Zimmerman explains, "Spartan, uncompromising and merciless are all adjectives that you could use to describe Cardassia." (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion)
* The courtroom was a redress of the holosuite set.
* This was the first episode directed by Avery Brooks.
* Sending the USS Enterprise-D to the DMZ was a tribute to Star Trek: The Next Generation, as "Tribunal" was the first Star Trek episode to air after TNG's series finale, "All Good Things...".
* This is the first mention that the Cardassians use cosmetic alterations in order to infiltrate their enemies. Later examples were Seska on Star Trek: Voyager whose true identity is revealed in the episode "State of Flux", and Gul Dukat, who masquerades as Anjohl Tennan in DS9 Season 7. This technique also played an important role in the DS9 episode "Second Skin".
* Armin Shimerman (Quark) and Cirroc Lofton (Jake Sisko) do not appear.

Poslali su enterprise na granicu s kardassiom


Sustav suđenja na kardasiji je zivo totalitarno ugrubo receno sranje , istina nema nasilja kad su i nevini i krivi osuđeni pa nitko zapravo ne zeli bit osuđen (cim je i optuzen , odmah je osuđen) , najgora je stvar sto ne dopustaju da se iznesu novi dokazi a samim time nema nit barem spustanja kazne ili uvjetne kazne , no u obrienovu slucaju nisu se htjeli osramotit pred narodom i pokazat svoju spletku pa su ga osudili na pustanje (obriena) , zao mi je sto ent nisu i slikovno prikazali a ne samo spomenuli , inace spletka kardassianaca je bila dosta domisljata , iako ne i originalna

ps mislim da prvi put vidimo kardassiu

8

dobra epizoda..
najbolji dio kad Odo kaže onom odvjedniku da je pobjedijo a on nato kaže da ga sad budu ubili...
to sve govori o njihovom sustavu

Eto nam prve "O'Brien Must Suffer" epizode... jadan Mile

A bas je sve simpatino krenulo na pocetku...
Bio je urnebesan kad je svima govorio na sto sve trebaju paziti dok ga nema, pomalo isao svima na zivce... i kad su vec mislili da je otisao, jos mu je na pola glava izvirila iz lifta i nastavio je pricati
I romanticne trenutke s Keiko mu pokvarise bad guysi...

Sto se tice 'obrade' - jos je i super prosao s obzirom na to kako se inace Kardasijanci ponasaju prema zarobljenicima...

Tko se sjeca prijasnje epizode kad je Dukat spomenuo njihov pravni sistem, nije mu bilo iznenadjenje sto je O Brien osudjn unaprijed, a sudjenje je tu samo kao show - da drugi vide udovice kako jecaju, osudjenike kako se kaju i sl. a sve u cilju odrzavanja totalitarnog sustava.... koma...
Odvjetnik (kao najbolji na Kardasiji) je tu samo kao figura koja ce sprovesti volju vlasti... bez ikakve zelje da nesto promjeni... totalno ispranog mozga...

Sutkinja koja s gadjenjem prica kako je to vec ionako najduze sudjenje u povijesti Kardasije

Dobar je bio kad je pred kraj rekao da ne priznaje taj kardasijanski sud... skoro ko jedna parola donedavno prisutna u nasim krajevima

A Odo je bio GENIJALAN sa izjavom "I regret I have no teeth to offer your Bureau of Identification."

Mile , žan i benjamin patnika tri sto su bolan jadni ucinili , zle sile na njih se sruse ali im dusa ne otpuse
Mile , žan i benjamin , patnika tri svoj travnik su promasili , otisli u svemir gdje vlada nemir i svijetla je uvijek pet
Mile , žan i benjamin patnika tri svoje snove su odsanjali

(Mile obrijan , žan luk pikard i benjamin siskomehmedovic)

--------------
Parodija